Ploff.net
  • What is Ploff?
  • Videos
  • About Us





BA 127 – Precaution Principle for Whom

On 13 Oct, 2013
Boletin
By : Brian Longstaff
With 1 Comment
Views : 13706
Compartí este articulo

More Moral Courage and the Precaution Principle taken backwards.

Days at university go on as a storm made of clouds charged with natural revolutionary wisdom. The moral courage, doing the right thing when the right thing is needed to be done, a way of doing what you feel is right, not hesitating. To feel, and do it: A reversion of Descartes’ I think, therefore I am.

BA 127 - SAB - Cultura Ambiental

In a nourishing class given by Prof. Jorge Caviglia on Natural Resources Economics, we debated in class about the role of culture –total salvation– in enhancing our environmental management. And on how the legal frame brings rules to the game to several different sectors of the economy and, hence, to our natural resources extractive system and further contamination. Laws allow, in an uthopical sense, but tangible, regulate, control, and punish those who contaminate.

The General Environmental National Law, says that all decisions coming from the government must contemplate the environment (Art N°5). And the Environmental National Policy Principles of Prevention and Precaution (Art N°4) FORCE A JUDGE TO ACT when called by society to defend nature.

The Prevention Principle gives priority to everything related to the environment, regarding any activity or decision. The Precaution Principle says you can ask to stop an activity, whenever doubt prevails in analyzing if that activity is making a negative impact over the environment; this is, with no scientific backup whatsoever: if there is a doubt, just stop!

Hence, if in the short term, money is generated by exploiting our environmental goods (everything nature gives us and we sell cheaply to another country while buying it back in the form of products form “high developed” countries), if we make it quick, the only thing that is left are fat bank accounts of who knows who. Nevertheless, in the long term, it is obvious that it is better to preserve our resources in order to keep on enjoying the environmental services provided by nature: food, raw materials, regulation of our climate, the cleansing of accumulated contamination, etc.

BA 127 - SAB - Servicios Ambientales

Those environmental services should have a great value, granted by a conscious culture, which is emerging nowadays, in order to manifest through a legal framework of a sustainable fashion that protects the environment by mere application of the precaution principle.

“The environmental goods must be seen like the natural stock given by nature and that, functionally, provide the environmental service. Generally speaking, that stock has no market related to its function, a key aspect which distorts its real value, generating flaws.” (Caviglia, 2013)

In another class we had on Ecology, we were debating with Prof. Jaime Bernardos on the viability of realizing certain calculations which imply sampling information from many different samples in order to arrive to a conclusion.

Simply said, if we think, for example, of an entire population of pigeons, it might cost a lot of money to take samples of all the pigeons, one by one, in order to know how many there are. And maybe, if we make the effort of counting down every single pigeon, the conclusions we will find might lack the importance required for not presenting new ideas. Hence, some investigation projects, and some areas within science, are not investigated because it is very expensive to push on through with the required sampling to sustain what we believe is happening and want to prove.

BA 127 - SAB - Glifosato

And there is a terrible consequence taken forward by the companies which have great environmental impact (either by massive extraction of raw materials or by the wastes they generate). For example, a company like Monsanto denies doing a study on the true long term impact of the use of glyphosate, because it is simply very expensive to put forward an investigation on every single soy plant. It is economically unviable and, maybe, it is not worth doing it from a business point of view, as we are not sure we are going to obtain negative results.

And I wonder… businesses like this one… don’t they have the Precaution Principle applied to them right away? Do judges who defend our planet really exist? It seems not, because here we have the Precaution Principle applied the other way round, because here the companies yell to the State: I will keep on contaminating until you confirm that we are actually contaminating. And the State also hasn`t got the money to take forward those investigations required to defend our planet, and we have no precaution at all.

In the words of Prof. Caviglia: “The way a society gives importance and value to the environment for its own development, the way she expresses nature´s cultural appreciation. She will be visible in the design of policies that condition the economic activity, controlling the power of the market to resolve the valorization of our natural resources.”

Nothing new… change culture, in order to change consumption habits in a natural manner, and change the system from the inside out.

Until next week,

Brian Longstaff.-

 

Bibliography.

This newsletter has been inspired by the theoretical classes given in October by professors Jaime Bernardos and Jorge Caviglia in Ecology 1 and Economy of the Natural Recourses respectively.

The pictures were created by Sabrina Tellini, traveler of time and life designer. Thanx for your visit!

Comments


Compartí este articulo


Tags :   Coraje MoralEcologíaEcologyeconomíaEconomyLey General del AmbienteMonsantoMoral CouragePrincipio de Precaución

Previous Post Next Post 

Related Posts

  • BA 194 – Nuevos Pobres, ¡despierten!

  • BA 176 – Travelling towards common grounds you get to horizontal leadership.

  • (Español) BA 253 – Argentina, República Extractivista: La irresponsabilidad de los que producen responsablemente.

  • BA 129 – Trying to understand money in an election day.-

Comments ( 1 )

  • Miguel Angel Guerrero Oct 13 , 2013 at 10:30 PM / Reply

    En mi opinión, todo pasa por política. En nuestra querida Patria Argentina faltan políticos que hagan cumpliar las leyes dictadas por el Congreso, como son en este caso las ambientales. Si cierran un acuerdo con X empresa se debe respetar las claúsulas y/o artículos. Se debe crear Entes Reguladores, o mejorar los actuales, que las controlen, y otros para sancionar el NO cumplimiento. Pero a estos acuerdo, influye mucho la parte social (Grandes empresas toman mucha mano de obra) en donde dejan pasar muchas cosas como por ejemplo contaminar el ambiente. Como no se ve yá, ahora, no se preocupan. Pero a futuro se sabe que tenemos recusrsos devastados, sin servicios ni bienes. Todos deberíamos pensar viendo el futuro de nuestros recursos sean polítcos o ciudadanos comunes ("Una mente Sustentable") .-


Leave a Comment

Click here to cancel reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.




Search

Downloads

   
  • Boletines populares
  • (Español) BA 248 – Relato Fantástico Distópico #2: “Oyendo Voces”.

    137323 views
  • BA 125 – What are we thinking about… Rain Water River Atuel

    83039 views
  • Boletín Consciente Nº 28

    41973 views
  • Awareness Newsletter N° 108

    32894 views
  • Boletín Consciente N.º1

    19361 views
  • Boletín Consciente Nº 25

    19095 views
  • BA 124 – Bonds, Thinking Journalism, Culture and Free Energy for the entire Human Race.-

    18742 views
  • BA 126 – Satirical illustrations of reality

    17247 views
  • BA 112 – Ill fated Publicity, a forgotten National Constitution and a Constitutional Protection for the Earth

    15708 views
  • BA 144 – Society and Madness

    14156 views
  • BA 141 – The truth behind the exponential growth of the human species.

    14130 views
  • BA 127 – Precaution Principle for Whom

    13706 views
  • BA 150 – The glass is always full, never empty.

    13080 views
  • Boletín Consciente N° 100

    13032 views
  • BA 142 – Three years of Ploffness

    12902 views
  • BA 136 – Camping helps you generate a mental-sacking.

    12859 views
  • Boletín Consciente N°18

    11608 views
  • Boletín Consciente N° 20

    11583 views
  • Boletín Consciente N° 50

    11199 views
  • (Español) Comunicado Ploffístico

    11185 views

Facebook

About Us

Ploff is a site to share information, articles and possible solutions to the reality the human being has created. Look at the video and find out more!

Subscribe

Get our updates by email!


© Copyright 2025 Ploff.net. All Rights Reserved.